Deathbringer

W:O:A Metalmaster
13 März 2009
5.281
0
81
37
Massachusetts
Yes it's a well known fact that it exists everywhere, America can't take credit for owning it. However, when it gets to a point that people are getting hurt and or killed because of it, it becomes something to act upon, so why wait until it grows to that level? To take any movement lightly and just brush it off as a few idiots who will do nothing more than talk about their beliefs is foolish. That has been proven more than a few times. There's a thing called being proactive versus being reactive. being proactive can save lives etc. And yes I agree the Varg thing is just stupid.

Being proactive can save lives, but there is a fine line between being proactive and limiting speech. Being an extremist is a thing that's tossed around almost as much as being a Nazi is. I've been called an extremist by my economics teacher because I believe in moderation in everything and living in a budget. To him, that's an extreme ideology. So, who's the one calling the shots in being proactive when one of the marks of an extremist is to demonize the enemy?

Hate groups, they're just mostly adults with no friends ranting on forums because they have nothing better to do. But, ranting is technically freedom of speech and even I've said things i probably shouldn't have that I didn't mean during a rant.
 

DarkCapricorn

W:O:A Metalmaster
4 Aug. 2008
7.151
0
81
Asgard
www.facebook.com
Being proactive can save lives, but there is a fine line between being proactive and limiting speech. Being an extremist is a thing that's tossed around almost as much as being a Nazi is. I've been called an extremist by my economics teacher because I believe in moderation in everything and living in a budget. To him, that's an extreme ideology. So, who's the one calling the shots in being proactive when one of the marks of an extremist is to demonize the enemy?

Hate groups, they're just mostly adults with no friends ranting on forums because they have nothing better to do. But, ranting is technically freedom of speech and even I've said things i probably shouldn't have that I didn't mean during a rant.

looks like for your economics teacher, to have own ideias and not be part of the system is to be an extremist. fair enough...
 

808Metal

W:O:A Metalmaster
30 Nov. 2007
46.286
0
81
Oahu, Hawaii
You don't know it's going to grow to be anything though. Or should we ban Bathory or Belphegor for singing about killing Christians? Or any band singing about killing people in general? That's where the double standard comes into play. You can't ban one hate group without banning the other and still call it fair. The only difference is the sensitivity toward Nazism.

Well the Black Metal movement to my knowledge does not have a history of mass murder, though there has been murder between some band members. The Nazi movement does. And the same goes for Black metal, don't go to their shows if you don't like them, that's the best way to take a stand as an individual. My point is the Nazi movement needs to be monitored/watched. If it goes un-monitored and becomes a violent and deadly movement then we can't just sit back and say, "Oh well, it's freedom of opinion".
 

808Metal

W:O:A Metalmaster
30 Nov. 2007
46.286
0
81
Oahu, Hawaii
Being proactive can save lives, but there is a fine line between being proactive and limiting speech. Being an extremist is a thing that's tossed around almost as much as being a Nazi is. I've been called an extremist by my economics teacher because I believe in moderation in everything and living in a budget. To him, that's an extreme ideology. So, who's the one calling the shots in being proactive when one of the marks of an extremist is to demonize the enemy?

Hate groups, they're just mostly adults with no friends ranting on forums because they have nothing better to do. But, ranting is technically freedom of speech and even I've said things i probably shouldn't have that I didn't mean during a rant.

I've never said we should limit speach, or control people's thoughts and beliefs. What I do believe is that when a force or group gains momentum and potentially becomes a threat to innocent people, it needs to be monitored, and if necessary, stopped. As for your economics teacher, he sounds like an idiot.
 

Deathbringer

W:O:A Metalmaster
13 März 2009
5.281
0
81
37
Massachusetts
Well the Black Metal movement to my knowledge does not have a history of mass murder, though there has been murder between some band members. The Nazi movement does. And the same goes for Black metal, don't go to their shows if you don't like them, that's the best way to take a stand as an individual. My point is the Nazi movement needs to be monitored/watched. If it goes un-monitored and becomes a violent and deadly movement then we can't just sit back and say, "Oh well, it's freedom of opinion".

Monitored, yes, but the sensitivity needs to wane a bit. In my opinion, to be NSBM, your band should actually have to HAVE lyrics based around it, not just have some random guy say they're ns because god forbid they sing about their culture's history, mythology and pride concerning it..

I know Christians have been prosecuted a bit throughout history. Not necessarily by the group doing the music though. Pagans were prosecuted by the Christians and well, things seem to be going quite well for them ;)
 

808Metal

W:O:A Metalmaster
30 Nov. 2007
46.286
0
81
Oahu, Hawaii
And by the way, I am just stating my opinions, and I respect yours as well. It's healthy to have mature discussions on issues like this.
 

Deathbringer

W:O:A Metalmaster
13 März 2009
5.281
0
81
37
Massachusetts
I've never said we should limit speach, or control people's thoughts and beliefs. What I do believe is that when a force or group gains momentum and potentially becomes a threat to innocent people, it needs to be monitored, and if necessary, stopped. As for your economics teacher, he sounds like an idiot.

Yeah.. he really was.

And, obviously monitor situations like that. But, even the most mainstream group can cause a threat to innocent people.
 

xforeverxmetalx

W:O:A Metalgod
29 Dez. 2007
97.363
7
123
Well the Black Metal movement to my knowledge does not have a history of mass murder, though there has been murder between some band members. The Nazi movement does. And the same goes for Black metal, don't go to their shows if you don't like them, that's the best way to take a stand as an individual. My point is the Nazi movement needs to be monitored/watched. If it goes un-monitored and becomes a violent and deadly movement then we can't just sit back and say, "Oh well, it's freedom of opinion".

I don't... only reason I've seen Belphegor twice is because they've been on tours with bands I do like [they manage to get stuck on anything...]. But you won't see me cheering for them or headbanging, the same way I only bounce a bit to Kreator's Enemy of God when they play it live.

I do agree it has to be watched of course. I don't want that part of history to be repeated either. Just, you'll never hear me agree that NSBM bands should be banned from playing shows in Germany or anywhere else. Boycott them if you want, break their CDs if you want, fine. But there's a line of preserving freedom of speech/opinion, and I think that preventing bands to exist, release CDs, or play shows is crossing that line, personally.
 

DarkCapricorn

W:O:A Metalmaster
4 Aug. 2008
7.151
0
81
Asgard
www.facebook.com
Well the Black Metal movement to my knowledge does not have a history of mass murder, though there has been murder between some band members. The Nazi movement does. And the same goes for Black metal, don't go to their shows if you don't like them, that's the best way to take a stand as an individual. My point is the Nazi movement needs to be monitored/watched. If it goes un-monitored and becomes a violent and deadly movement then we can't just sit back and say, "Oh well, it's freedom of opinion".

then let them be monitored but putting the blame in someone who doesn't have any fault of this thing is bad. never been a fan of politics or movements connected to that for a reason... this is one them. politics blind people to the point that they couldn't see the things clearly. as you can see, i'm going to see varg and i'm glad that they could play at wacken, but if them or any other band, start with politic bullshit, i'll leave. there's plently of beer there and other bands to see there.
 

808Metal

W:O:A Metalmaster
30 Nov. 2007
46.286
0
81
Oahu, Hawaii
Monitored, yes, but the sensitivity needs to wane a bit. In my opinion, to be NSBM, your band should actually have to HAVE lyrics based around it, not just have some random guy say they're ns because god forbid they sing about their culture's history, mythology and pride concerning it..

I know Christians have been prosecuted a bit throughout history. Not necessarily by the group doing the music though. Pagans were prosecuted by the Christians and well, things seem to be going quite well for them ;)

yes I agree, you're not an NSBM band if you don't sing about the topic. And if a guy in a band wears a certain T-shirt, it is not reason to chastise his band. I love the song Angel of Death, but I'm not stupid enough to think that Slayer were trying to say The Joseph Mengele was a good person or what he did was good, quite the opposite in fact. I am all for singing about history and historic events, positive or not. History is not always pretty, but it should not be forgotten.